新华网:草台班子、金钱交易,南海仲裁庭猫腻说不清

韩墨/新华网

2016-07-15 13:51 来源:澎湃新闻

字号
三沙市的政府驻地西沙永兴岛。 东方IC 资料图
连日来,菲律宾南海仲裁案临时仲裁庭公布所谓“裁决”,不仅仲裁结果之荒唐让世人震惊,其临时仲裁庭本身的可信度也受到广泛质疑,成为笑料。
先是联合国明确表示临时仲裁庭和它没有任何关系,接着国际法院也声明自己是完全不同的另一机构。人们都越发看清,所谓仲裁庭不过是拼凑起来的“草台班子”,其所作所为之离谱,已让此“裁决”注定成为国际法历史上一个臭名昭著的荒唐案例。
荒唐之一是,名头不正
南海仲裁庭位于司法之都海牙,乍一听非常唬人,但实际上它与联合国主要机构之一的国际法院毫无关系,与同样在海牙“和平宫”租地办公的常设仲裁法院也不是一回事。对此,联合国中文官方微博和国际法院官方网站均予以澄清。
实际上,临时仲裁庭是2013年菲律宾单方面提起仲裁后,由时任国际海洋法法庭庭长的日本籍法官柳井俊二操办组织的一个临时班底。这个临时仲裁庭不过是租用了“和平宫”的场地而已,并以此拉大旗作虎皮,让许多不明真相的人上当。
依据国际法实践,这类仲裁机制从设立到运行,都必须得到当事国同意,并充分尊重当事国意愿。然而,南海仲裁庭自始至终都未得到中国的认同,因此从根本上就是“师出无名”,欺世盗名。
荒唐之二是,选人有猫腻
临时仲裁庭由5名仲裁员组成,除菲律宾指派1人外,其他4人均由柳井俊二指派。如出d{e[t]||(e柳䝇由Ane仲r 时15 13d="hds_inp" vgC,Y+:(有上海(裁Doma oa<
荒唐之>
<批iv 压 甲裁垝,div>事
荒唐之谓“r />意 得迡愁操迡荷兏iv>兏,接,䤖䭰亚洤ss=枫 styp" 旗g><院衡的,做ss='contheight'>
荒唐之二是,选人有驻腻
临时仲裁庭由充裁p浀谓“裕枋收费流且本/h1> 接
荒唐之其由iv 皆div上流裁案临裝,
  • 荒唐之俗class拿ong>短浀
    愁绝ongstr〶>叝s海仁结果䮃没有任div宾持机di>
    仲后牵强附iv 证,充裁根历后,div>e 史5玷污iv 神方决正乕的劣iv class='contheight'>
    荒唐之伌 />sty这类仦+:Ciiv >
    南海仲裁庭位处硬伤iv>劣庭 iv 证浖过昴时仲裁庭公>/div秀 ontent"> go line-日来: 20px;
    float:lefndapan st/super">ipt: _blank"ze="Detail_> line-日来: 20px;
    float:lefndapan st/super">ipt: _blank"ze="Detail_>超 o/javas url: "//adpai.the }= new sF连Siv .hrwwstore.addItem("
    js/jwoop=er.dFlsh.swvidurl: "//adpai.the } vN }d/13:epapdurl: "//adpai.the } vN }g" wi: (cread,url: "//adpai.the } vN }/file: weurl: "//adpai.the } vN }日来: hurl: "//adpai.the } vN cla } vN } vN }} } //将 h } vN = noop=U"http'',wrap Id='oop=er_wrap ',$wrap ttp$('#'+wrap Idcla } vN } vN }ttpoop=U"h){oop=(wrap Id,oop=U"h,'',$wrap ./file(),$wrap .日来())f (vclas/javas u(vcla!-- div>ong计 --> a!-- 空格>隤div 多旟--> hdbk" > n>

    4009-20-4009   n>

    eiv c <得 ht载 class=' ontent"> ze="s w/a>>> 时仲裁ss="news_tiath"> 连lseass="hdhiddength="20">149897lt=/super"ontent"> 马voteC连ar 事i 17as
    ontent"> nbgboxaspt:lgwdsshow();">马favoriteC连2( r 事收displa ontent"> 马tr iC连a r 事 y igro -28, 12#FFFFFFv url: "//adpai.the } var href = windadJ .cn/s?", c=51&WD-CLIENT-TYPE=05ache2&ars="149897l&cas="254/a>,boze="s/dolpn)as/javas u } vN } vN' } vN } vN'ath"> var href = win per.cn//s?", c=52&WD-CLIENT-TYPE=05aars="149897l&cas="254/a> /javas url: "//adpai.the' 5 13 var href = win url: "//adpai.thea } vN } vN") {!w!="ow.PLISTAleXmlRes(xml } vN }w!="ow.PLISTAttp} }); } vN s="bnc er.e56b08742796548b853acc95idurl: "//adpai.the } vNitem:p} }); } vN }objrefider.149897lteurl: "//adpai.the } vN }草er.班子、金钱交易,南海仲裁庭猫腻说不清
    ';s0; v"htNode) =if tBe>新华网:a>< (vclah2 ontent"> ct{ _bpn u(vclaath"> ct{ _lisuper">i aath"> ct{ _b =436">能ze="Detail_>/image.thepcn/dww/image/5/34/88g" width=1/624 heighpan s今Do虎="j(div> 方始>
    claath"> ct{ _name=436">能ze="Detail_>/今Do虎="j(div> 方始>
    ca aath"> ct{ _lisuper">i aath"> ct{ _b =436">能ze="Detail_>/image.thepcn/dww/2image/5/34/88g" width=6h="2 heighpan s这类长的日本籁釕 ,始至终都朁绌样圅报dvg
世胵蹦=43spla claath"> ct{ _name=436">能ze="Detail_>/这类长的日本籁釕 ,始至终都朁绌样圅报dvg
世胵蹦3spla ca aath"> ct{ _lione;"> i aath"> ct{ _b =436">能ze="Detail_> /image.thepcn/dww/1image/5/34/88g" widthth=54 heighpan s裁案临时仲裁庭公不清
    claath"> ct{ _name=436">能ze="Detail_> /裁案临时仲裁庭公不清
    ca 5 13:51 ct{ _lisuper">i aath"> ct{ _b =436">能ze="Detail_> /image.thepcn/dww/2image/5/34/88g" width=3/588 heighpan s俄军 始至蕴秼釦 仲矛盾=43spla claath"> ct{ _name=436">能ze="Detail_> /俄军 始至蕴秼釦 仲矛盾3spla ca (vcl 13< aath"rd"> ze="stita>(128, 1mm/a aath" 3sathdowvcaath" at:andard"ctnh v"_sina_detail_blank"picLink.rem} fu); ina('149897l','班子、金钱交易,南海仲裁庭猫腻说不清
    i- a aath"> classr"newscontent"> rtJsp"" var href = windadJ .cn/s?", c=45&WD-CLIENT-TYPE=05ache2&cas="254/a>,ba }a!--25950--> h/javas u= n(hrttpunction(.addElem"htById(irtJsp"class="bdwd mh3:andard"rthotze="stt/cla="dish3> hdbk" > 标.thep picLink.remov
    马府 as 马府周as <3sathdowver-新华umhota>< class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>新华umhota>< class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>新华umhot st class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>柳上烧仧那烧《cla臗p 》=iv 3spla< 新华umhot4st class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>新华umhotiv class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>新华umhotdiv class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>到坠v浈以澄裁>新华umhota>< class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>新华umhota>< class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>新华umhotdiv class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>新华umhot1div class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_><肖鹏《丝跏水仲]||div 殸掀'spla<
  • 新华umhota>< class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>>湖 双峻应v><追v>新华umhota>< class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>/diiv钉 cpla< 新华umhot st class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_> 金= cpla< 新华umhot4st class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>新华umhotiv class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>获亚新华umhotdiv class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>新华umhota>< class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>新华umhota>< class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_><>新华umhotdiv class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>柳上烧仧那烧《cla臗p 》=iv 3spla< 新华umhot1div class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>iv st仲
  • 新华umhota>< class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>>湖 双峻应v><追v>新华umhota>< class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>新华umhot st class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>新华umhot4st class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>新华umhotiv class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>新华umhotdiv class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>e=yl晚秀得驾le=诅浌yle队lediv 珠澳li 桥"lpla< 新华umhota>< class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_><浭 散落60<万 "lpla< 新华umhota>< class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>
    新华umhotdiv class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_>/diiv钉 cpla< 新华umhot1div class='t: _blank"ze="Detail_> 金= cpla< > /image per.cn/www/v3/img/logo116.png">b /ppzp hei?t=span0926"le=" <3sathdoaath"> rtap _"owsu }ap
    b /ap _"ow.pghpan s>er="lt= ifmap="#Mad/" }amap name="Mad/"/su } }aa{ nh yp="rref.deooa>s="87,161,146,av>/su } }aa{ nh yp="rref.deooa>s="3,186,80,208.thep //mhinfile/paper/2wnload?s="2t=/su } 标.thep picLink.remov
    马府 as 马府周as <3sathdower-新华umhota>< class=a } vN }apone;"> float:right;/file:180px;saa.thep assty上div>勇,j(div=另新华umhota>< class=a } vN }apone;"> float:right;/file:180px;saa.thep ass/y上福建e国
    新华umhot st class=a } vN }apone;"> float:right;/file:180px;saa.thep assty上新华umhot4st class=a } vN }apone;"> float:right;/file:180px;saa.thep ass / ="d/>到clas接么独特iv 春节习俗+:'spla新华umhotiv class=a } vN }apone;"> float:right;/file:180px;saa.thep ass /y上接偋la="div 骀亣la="di<喪無,j(养口la="d胵div ss=密, sne;">
  • 新华umhota>< class=a } vN }apone;"> float:right;/file:180px;saa.thep assty上新华umhota>< class=a } vN }apone;"> float:right;/file:180px;saa.thep ass /y上2008/di新华umhot st class=a } vN }apone;"> float:right;/file:180px;saa.thep ass /y上接偋la="div 骀亣la="di<喪無,j(养口la="d胵div ss=密, 新华umhot4st class=a } vN }apone;"> float:right;/file:180px;saa.thep ass/y上福建e国
    新华umhotiv class=a } vN }apone;"> float:right;/file:180px;saa.thep ass /y上演陈y,
  • 新华umhota>< class=a } vN }apone;"> float:right;/file:180px;saa.thep ass /y上演陈y,新华umhota>< class=a } vN }apone;"> float:right;/file:180px;saa.thep assty上新华umhot st class=a } vN }apone;"> float:right;/file:180px;saa.thep ass /y上接偋la="div 骀亣la="di<喪無,j(养口la="d胵div ss=密, 新华umhot4st class=a } vN }apone;"> float:right;/file:180px;saa.thep assty上div st秀le=<昤c罗翔,案dvg么要d,”做辩护, 新华umhotiv class=a } vN }apone;"> float:right;/file:180px;saa.thep ass/y上飸14>到iv>空,j(空iv>间>爱恨仇, hdbk" > rmtj_b =436" _blank"ze="Detail_> } } }ap436" _blank"ze="Detail_> rmtj_b =436" _blank"ze="Detail_>< b sner..cn/dww/image/5/34/88g" wid66002/312 heighpan siv cpla
  • } } }ap436" _blank"ze="Detail_> rmtj_b =436" _blank"ze="Detail_> } } }ap436" _blank"ze="Detail_> rmtj_b =436" _blank"ze="Detail_>< b sner..cn/dww/2image/5/34/88g" wid66060/62 /apan stv cpla } } }ap436" _blank"ze="Detail_>"lpla rmtj_b =436" _blank"ze="Detail_>< b sner..cn/dww/2image/5/34/88g" wid66081/77 /apan stv cpla } } }ap436" _blank"ze="Detail_><负奋斗亣法棅浌 aath"> rtJsp2t=< ath"> ifrht/a/javascript"> var href = windadJ .cn/s?", c=50&WD-CLIENT-TYPE=05ache2&cas="254/a>,bbottom/)as/javas aa } }a!--25950--> h/javas u= n(hrttpunction(.addElem"htById(irtJsp"class="bdwd m/javascript"> var href = wind"#heabh .href; iinnerHeight HTTunction(.unction(Elem"ht.ebnohtHeight("#heabw .href; iinnerWfile HTTunction(.unction(Elem"ht.ebnohtWfile("#heabdh .h(function(.".hetrim(ebnohtHeight("#heabdw .h(function(.".hetrim(ebnohtWfile("#healb ight c_head_ad a") $(日来()+("body").p(日来()+("boclassr"n$(日来()-260; 转 tyy顶娅亓>ey(fvideoHeadAd.} }$(w!="ow).o, llfvideoHeadAd.} }} }#hea
    e70a } vN") {$(w!="ow).o, llTop()>lb ighti} });ve()adc6op3 $(); } if adc6op3 $la } vN var adTypeStr = ve()adc6op3 $(dy").pCFlssundec6op3 $la } vN a } cla claass="bdwd m asathdow ath"> 墨/} }aa.thep 墨ref ">><>连acpaus">st联y"lpla }aa.thep >pyright_ catem"ht">><版 全"lpla }aa.thep ef Jsp">><>><Copyright © 2014~2018 The Pf A) {rights; if ved.div 时/yICP备14003370
      | 互联 cl="d div 的 31120170006a3sathdoaath"(128, 1/file:300px;新copyright">upat: _blank"aper.cn|hrebeian.gov.c/ ortal/reg国erSyemInfo?rreoa>code=310106020002 b /ghs.pgh(128, 1float:lefn;"lewvcpone;"> float:lefn=日来:20px;line-日来:20px;
    • h/javasass="hd;"> '] $(e if ("truemovethis$()); (vide"nof llowive.r clarionbottomf"> h!-- cnzzsneatstcdeode --> hath" var href = wind" #heacnzz_l !to28,}= ((adAd s:" =tpunction(.escat注l !to28,) ? > functio" er. fun://ive.rtunction(.write(unescf ("%3Cs="he hsathd"/javascript"> var href = win per.cn/www/v3/img/logo116.png">js/rp">iv clcript> h/javascript"> var href = wind"#heahotCmm}= ""laa }videoHeadeopyPaeInit(neart, ohd, l"hleXmlRes(xml#heaa}= unction(.addElem"htsBy Name("".he")rim;a } vN#head}= unction(.d flaeElem"ht("athrn; d.id}= tylcpDthr;a } vNd.(128,.posit}= tab reuter;a } vNd.(128,.); Evss=L国ener"er.)); Evss=a;a } vN#heabb}= ud}== ta); Evss=a ? >ideopy"er.eopy"la }}}}}") {!l"hlel"h}= 0la }}}}}a[dd](bb,h ileXmlRes(xml }") {dTypof(Tynt) { " efinedad"{a } vN } }rn(urna } vN }} } //将 h #heah}= uocum"ht.addS(hrefionar a } vN }") {h.isC llapsedd"{a } vN } }rn(urna } vN }} } //将 h #heag}= h.addRanieAt(0)(ebonC连"ht el a } vN }d.innerHTML}= ""la }}}}}}}}}d.appohdChild(gr a } vN }") {d.;">>eurl: "//adpai.therd">:.eols"149897lgeurl: "//adpai.thec er eurl: "//adpai.thesutmlsser unefionahtmh){( }}}}} }}}}}}}}}ttpunction(.addElem"htById(i (amtlse) { '') ){( }}}}} }}}}}}}}} }unction(.addElem"htById(iaq_>mm/lody").p"hild(docum"ht.addElem"htById(i (amtlse)r a } vN } }}}}}} } //将 h } v }ve()aq_>mm/$()ppohd(htmh) a } vN }}}}} }iono, lln>eurl: "//adpai.therd">:.eols"149897lg+"&} fuHot=0"+"&hotI>s="eurl: "//adpai.thec er eurl: "//adpai.thesutmlsser unefionahtmh){( }}}}} }}}}}}}}}ttpunction(.addElem"htById(i (amtlse) { '') ){( }}}}} }}}}}}}}} }unction(.addElem"htById(iaq_>mm/lody").p"hild(docum"ht.addElem"htById(i (amtlse)r a } vN } }}}}} }vew!="ow).unb!="('.info, '( }}}}} } }}}}}} } //将 h } v }ttpunction(.addElem"htById(ize="sassie) == '') ){( }}}}} }}}}}}}}} }ve()aq_>mm/$()ppohd(htmh) a } vN }}}}} }}aa } } }}}}}} } //将 h claa }}}}}}claa }}}}}ve()c(am_s="hs$(ebnc fvideoHeadAd.} }} } }ve() (am_s="hs$(dy").pCFlssuncurrn; }ve()cur_ ns i.); } if currn; }ttpunction(.addElem"htById(i (amtlse) { '') ){( }}}}} }}}}}rn(urn a } vN }} } //将 h $.aj e( }}}}} }}}}}pape"ze=Detail_ (amt">>eurl: "//adpai.thec er eurl: "//adpai.therd">:.eols"149897lgeurl: "//adpai.thesutmlsser unefionahtmh){( }}}}} }}}}}}}}}ttpunction(.addElem"htById(ize="sassie) { '') ){( }}}}} }}}}} }}}}}unction(.addElem"htById(iaq_>mm/lody").p"hild(docum"ht.addElem"htById(ize="sassie)) a } vN }}}}} } }vew!="ow).unb!="('.info, '( }}}}} } }}}}}} } //将 h } v }ttpunction(.addElem"htById(i (amtlse) == '') ){( }}}}} }}}}}}}}} }ve()aq_>mm/$()ppohd(htmh) a } vN }}}}} }}a }}}}} }}}}}} } //将 h cla }}}}}}claa }}}}}ve(.
      )){( }}}}} }}}}}rn(urn a } vN }}e {( }}}}} }}}}}vethis$()r("id","selectsi"bnng elody").p"id","selec error: } vNve(uze="stxtrn.dy").pCFlssuze="siv $(); } ifliIDn.)); rd">
      h/javasass="hd;">,bappeicatTime":504,"be >:"bam.nr-rd">uzet>,bqueueTime":0,ieohseKey"e"bc78c5daa2>,btr nsacpionName"e"ZwZVN0ADXEdZBUNcVl5MYAZQMVdGTg9UUBZTDFpNRQ1cUF0UQ1BSHg5YAVsOV0JRAlJaF1MMRQYcC1xAXRRWVk1ZDFlNQQdAQlEFUht6Xw5aBlwWf1VWB1BQSx8EUhdxDV9ZXQhDdlhTC1I="e")ges=a:""e"errorBe >:"bam.nr-rd">uzet>} clcript>